Page 1 of 1

Re: POLL: APHELION FLASH FICTION CONTEST:July 2015

PostPosted: August 06, 2015, 10:12:02 AM
by kailhofer
Sounds to me like everybody was good on word count. Even if there was an issue, Ed's running this contest, and he allowed it, so there is still no issue. A final ruling is just that, final.

BTW, even when I ran the contest, I gave everybody one story where they could break the rule a little in a "first one's free" sort of way. There is precedent for this, so relax, everybody. We're ok here.

Re: POLL: APHELION FLASH FICTION CONTEST:July 2015

PostPosted: August 14, 2015, 08:11:45 PM
by Lester Curtis
My votes are in ... I almost didn't make it.

Re: POLL: APHELION FLASH FICTION CONTEST:July 2015

PostPosted: August 16, 2015, 12:08:39 PM
by Lester Curtis
Yeah, that was me. Sorry; I've sent the missing score by PM if it'll help.

Re: POLL: APHELION FLASH FICTION CONTEST:July 2015

PostPosted: August 17, 2015, 05:36:33 PM
by Lester Curtis
Congrats, Joey!

Eddie, you did well too, placing second. My top vote went to Michele this time. Here's how I marked 'em up:

Waste Management
1) Overall: 7
2) Characterization: 5
3) Plot: 5
4) Setting: 7
5) Dialog: 9
6) Challenge: 10

total: 43

comments: Difficult to follow; felt like pieces were missing. I'm guessing that indicates cuts to make the word count; I've turned out a few myself that felt that way for that reason.

The Beast, Within
1) Overall: 5
2) Characterization: 6
3) Plot: 4
4) Setting: 4
5) Dialog: 6
6) Challenge: 10

total: 35

A Fairy Familiar Tale
1) Overall: 7
2) Characterization: 7
3) Plot: 8
4) Setting: 6
5) Dialog: 4
6) Challenge: 10

total: 42

Twenty Questions
1) Overall: 9
2) Characterization: 7
3) Plot: 10
4) Setting: 7
5) Dialog: 7
6) Challenge: 10

total: 50

The Case of the Calendar Jar Crimes...
1) Overall: 7
2) Characterization: 7
3) Plot: 8
4) Setting: 6
5) Dialog: 5
6) Challenge: 10

total: 43

Flash Suppressor
1) Overall: 5
2) Characterization: 4
3) Plot: 8
4) Setting: 4
5) Dialog: 3
6) Challenge: 10

total: 34

comments: Heavy info-dump via dialog—and the narrator is dead.
______________
Sorry I didn't take the time to come up with more (and better) comments; I've been busy with a personal obsession for a while and it's cut into all sorts of stuff.