Page 1 of 1

Alter Id by McCamy Taylor

PostPosted: December 20, 2007, 11:39:20 AM
by GDJ
An enjoyable yarn, full of plenty of classis SFnal ingredients: cyborgs, lunar mining, criminal deportation, and lots of gadgets. I enjoyed it, right up until the final sentence that doesn't read quite right. I had to re-read it twice to make it out, which was a shame as it lessened the impact of the conclusion.

Re: Alter Id by McCamy Taylor

PostPosted: January 06, 2008, 12:36:59 PM
by kailhofer
Interesting and complicated story. I agree with Gareth about all those SF ingredients.

Neat idea.

All of it worked for me except the conclusion. It was too pat. The Doctor just happens to know all the right union leaders to stop the evil corporation's plot dead in its tracks. The cyborg assassin goes along with changing back into his weak, servant self (with a little protesting, I realize), when he could have had his own, stronger agenda. I mean, he really doesn't have to change back, does he? Who's going to make him if he doesn't want to? The girlfriend is forgiven outright for a complete betrayal that brought murderers into their home. Then, the Doc announces his plans to use the cyborg to help all those like him.

Somewhat benevolent for a mad scientist with a recognized god complex, I thought.


Re: Alter Id by McCamy Taylor

PostPosted: January 08, 2008, 12:17:50 PM
by McCamy_Taylor
Thanks for the feedback. As you very perceptively note, the ending is way too pat. That is probably because as I was finishing it I was thinking about a sequel, and this was meant to be a pause.

What characters with God complexes say is not necessarily what authors intend to let them do. Re-integrating multiple personalities is beyond the type of medical science that the doctor specializes in---and probably is not in the best medical interest of Adam. It certainly is not in the interest of the author.

I will probably tinker with the ending to make it more ambiguous, the way I intended it to be.